Chicken Thighs & Rum BBQ Sauce

13/08/2021 by Living the Gourmet 33 Comments

Today we’re preparing a homemade Rum BBQ Sauce. The sauce features nice a touch of heat courtesy of jalapenos and chili paste, savory notes from teriyaki and garlic, and sweetness from basil and fresh orange juice. This is all brought together using a base of brown sugar reduced in rum.

The end result is a delicious, decadently thick, sweet and spicy sauce that’s perfect on all kinds of grilled meats, from barbecued steaks to grilled chicken thighs, even French fries and onion rings are a great match.

Why Make Your Own BBQ Sauce?

1) Control the Ingredients. The honest trust about store bought condiments is that ‘very’ few are of decent quality. It’s simply too cost efficient to mask subpar ingredients behind walls of blinding heat, mouth-parching saltiness, or obscene amounts of sugar and thickness – or some combination thereof. Add onto that the fact that store bought condiments (usually) need to have an absurd shelf life, and the mosaic of ‘why’ there are so few truly quality condiments out there begins to come together. Generally, the fewer and simpler ingredients a store bought sauce has the better, such as my preferred brand of super-basic chili paste (which I talk about below). When you make your own, you bypass all of this, since the ingredients are wholly under your control.

2) Super Simple. I won’t call today’s recipe ‘easy,’ but I won’t call it ‘complex’ either. Basically, just combine all of the ingredients in a sauce pan, and simmer – but don’t boil – for about thirty minutes, or until the sauce thickens. Simple.

3) It honestly ‘does’ taste better. The combination of flavors, and the ‘freshness’ evident in today’s sauce, is simply leagues above anything you’ll get out of a jar. Trust me.

Ingredient Notes, Tips, and Substitutions

1) The Chili Paste. This is an ingredient that is so versatile I truly don’t know how a kitchen functions without it. Chili paste works wonders as a base for everything from marinades to homemade hot sauces, or for adding some spice to red sauces or salsas, or even serving as a condiment on its own for meat, eggs, and fish, where it brings pungency, spice, and bright ‘chili flavor.’ That said, I don’t personally use a fancy or ‘hard to find’ chili paste – and honestly, you shouldn’t either. On the contrary, I use an Indonesian Sambal chili paste that sells for a couple of dollars per jar. It’s a super basic mix of chilis, salt, and vinegar. It’s hot, not overly thick, and allows the pungency and spice of the chilis to really shine through.

Should you make your own? No, no not really. I know there are a lot of recipes online for how to make chili paste, and honestly it’s just not worth the trouble. Yes, it’s (relatively) easy and (very) inexpensive, but at the end of the day, store bought chili paste ‘does’ taste just as good as similarly structured homemade recipes – and is already really inexpensive on its own. Sure, if you want to ‘fancy up’ a particular chili paste recipe, go for it, but for use in things like today’s recipe, store bought works just fine.

Substitution: An equal amount of ‘plain’ Sriracha works ‘almost’ as well – but Sriracha brings a lot of extra flavors with it (due to being a lot more than just chilis, salt, and vinegar), and surprisingly Sriracha is quite a bit ‘cooler.’ Regular chili paste brings a good bit more kick, and a ‘purer’ chili flavor. Thus, while not ‘ideal,’ Sriracha is an ‘okay’ substitute.

2) Brown Sugar – Tasty, but what is it? There are two types of brown sugar, refined and unrefined. Refined brown sugar is simply white sugar to which molasses has been added. Unrefined brown sugar, as the name implies, undergoes less processing to allow the sugar to retain more of its original, naturally occurring molasses. In other words, the difference between white and brown sugar is the presence of molasses, which gives brown sugar its signature ‘sticky’ texture and caramel-like flavor. Contrary to popular misconception, brown sugar (both kinds) and processed white sugar are almost identical nutritionally. This is the case since virtually all commercially available sugar originates from sugarcane, the juice of which – as the name implies – contains meteoric levels of sugar. For reference, a mere 100 grams of freshly pressed sugarcane juice contains 73 grams of sugar. This juice is then refined and processed to produce molasses, which is then further refined to produce brown sugar, which in turn is then further refined to create white sugar. This refining process does nothing apart from filtering out more and more of the original sugarcane plant to isolate and crystalize the sugar itself.

3) Rum – The Star of the Show. Let’s start off by saying that, as with almost any recipe calling for alcohol, I like to follow two simple rules. The first is “Do not cook with an alcohol that you wouldn’t enjoy on its own.” The second is “Do not cook with pricey or otherwise ‘high quality’ alcohol.” These are ‘not’ contradictory rules. The taste of the alcohol is invariably going to influence your food – otherwise why would you be cooking with it? – and as such, you want that influence to be ‘tasty’ and ‘pleasant.’ Thus, cook with an alcohol that you would enjoy on its own. However, boiling alcohol ‘does’ remove a lot of the nuance and ‘finer’ qualities that make ‘fine’ alcohol ‘fine.’ As such, there’s no sense in boiling away the ‘finer points’ of a quality alcohol, since those ‘finer points’ are what make the alcohol quality in the first place.

What this Means: Use a ‘decent’ but not ‘pricey’ rum.

Today’s Sauce Pairs Great With

1) French Fries. Homemade fries and today’s BBQ sauce are a match made heaven. I prepare mine oven-baked with a dusting of cayenne, garlic, and pepper.

2) Onion Rings. Today’s BBQ sauce goes great with fried onion rings. I prepare my onion rings with just a hint of spice, and a thick, dense batter that crisps up beautifully during frying.

3) All the Meats. Whether we’re talking about fried chicken, grilled pork or BBQ’d ribs today’s sauce is a simply delicious pairing.

However, how can you be sure you’re buying quality meat? And is there any way to get quality meat that doesn’t require breaking the bank? Sure, you can inspect every piece and package you buy, or seek out a pricy butchery, or just ‘hope for the best.’ Sure, you can do that, or you can do what I do; opt for ButcherBox.

The main idea behind ButcherBox is that everyone can – and should – have access to high-quality, humanely raised meat. To this end, ButchBox is an affordable source of 100% grass-fed ‘and’ grass-finished beef, free-range organic chicken, pork that’s been raised crate-free, wild-caught seafood, all delivered to your door each month in 100% recycled packaging. Now, given what I just described, you’re probably wondering just how affordable ButchBox really is, and the answer is that the average price of a meal from ButcherBox is just $6 USD, and shipping is always free.

That’s right, no shipping cost – ever.

Now, while ButcherBox naturally has all of the familiar cuts of beef and pork that everyone knows and loves, ButcherBox is also a great way to experiment, since they stock rare and unique cuts that you’ll almost never find in the grocery store.

So, what are you waiting for? Sign up, become a member and start receiving monthly boxes of high quality, affordable meat. Yes, you customized your box on the fly, and members receive exclusive deals, priority access to new products, and a support team that’s available 24/7.

Seriously, ButcherBox is the modern butcher’s market for busy shoppers. Try them out today, I love them, and I know you will too.

Chicken Thighs & Rum BBQ Sauce

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

5 from 11 reviews

Author: Living the Gourmet
Total Time: 1 hour
Yield: 4-6 1x

Save Recipe

Print Recipe

Ingredients

Scale

8 bone-in chicken thighs – with skin

For the Rum BBQ Sauce:

1/2 cup dark brown sugar
1/2 cup of rum
1 jalapeno - sliced thin with seeds
4 - 5 cloves of garlic - chopped
5 - 6 fresh basil leaves - chopped
1 tbs. apple cider vinegar
1 tbs. fresh orange juice
2 tbs. teriyaki sauce
1 cup ketchup
1 tsp. chili paste
Dashes of fresh ground black pepper

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Combine all of the ingredients for the bbq sauce in a medium cast-iron pan and stir.
Simmer on a gentle heat for about 20 – 30 minutes; until the sauce thickens.
Preheat Oven 350 degrees F.
Reserve half of the bbq sauce in a covered container. This will last in the refrig for about 2 weeks, covered.
Place the chicken thighs in a large bowl and pour about half of the bbq sauce into the bowl.
DO NOT place the spoon that you use to toss the chicken back in the reserved bbq sauce.
Place the chicken thighs in a large cast iron frying pan.
Bake for 50 – 55 minutes.

Notes

**I doubled my recipe since I wanted enough bbq sauce on the side to serve with the chicken thighs. Also this bbq sauce makes a great dipping sauce for French fries and such.

Prep Time does NOT include Inactive Prep Time.